Pastor Art Lucier’s Appeal Challenging Constitutional Rights Infringement Goes to Court

On Tuesday in BC Supreme Court in Kelowna, the legal challenge of Pastor Art Lucier, who was fined $2,300 for hosting a service at the Kelowna Harvest Church against COVID-19 gathering restrictions issued by Provincial Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry on Jan. 8, 2021 came to court. Lucier’s lawyer Marty Moore with the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms argued that his client is being prosecuted on the basis of an infringement of his rights.

The judge likely referred to prior legal challenges targeting health orders that have failed and stated “If an infringement of constitutional rights as the Crown admits took place here… can be imposed by governments through an unelected delegate of power through the Ministry of Health… and then prevent somebody in the criminal courts from raising a constitutional defence…the principles here go far beyond the interests of Lucier.”

In a news release Monday, Moore said that if this decision were allowed to stand it would mean that governments could void Canadians’ Charter rights simply by issuing administrative decisions and providing a dysfunctional process of administrative review. The two day appeal hearing was scheduled to wrap up on Tuesday, but a decision will likely not be available for several days afterwards at least.

The case of Pastor Art Lucier has shed light on how Canadian Charter rights are applicable when challenged by governmental restrictions, especially during times like these when health concerns dictate emergency measures taken at different levels across provinces and territories. Though governments may have been responding to an urgent need to contain outbreaks, such cannot come at the expense of individual freedoms constitutionally protected under law – especially since implementing statutory laws is often time consuming and thus impractical during emergencies.

The outcome of this case will therefore be watched very closely, as it sets precedent for citizens exercising their right to freedom and justice whenever governmental intervention infringes upon it – as well as establish whether or not citizens must exhaust legal remedies provided beforehand before challenging restrictions deemed unjustified or arbitrary. In addition, it will also shape both current and future attempts made by health officials trying to contain pandemics while protecting people’s rights such as assembly or peaceful protest and bringing balance between public health objectives with those guaranteed under law.

Featured Articles

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act, is shaking up the real estate market.

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act, is shaking up the real estate market.

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the “residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act,” is shaking up the real estate market.The...

Penticton Vees Dog Race

Penticton Vees Dog Race

The Penticton Vees are hosting their annual Pucks N' Paws night on Saturday, February 17th, and they have something special planned for this year's event. During the first intermission of the game against the West Kelowna Warriors, the Vees will be holding their first...

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act, is shaking up the real estate market.

Penticton Man Strikes it Rich with $100K Lotto 6/49 Win

In an incredible stroke of luck, a Penticton man has become $100,000 richer after winning the Lotto 6/49. Steven Wilson, a local resident, is now celebrating his life-changing win.The thrilling news came as a surprise to Wilson, who purchased the winning ticket at a...

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act, is shaking up the real estate market.

Last Passenger Train Service Departs from Penticton in 1964

In 1964, Penticton bid farewell to its beloved passenger train service. This historic event marked the end of an era, leaving behind memories and stories for generations to come.Sixty years ago, on January 17th, locals from Summerland boarded the final train bound for...

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act, is shaking up the real estate market.

Special events guide: Feb. 1-6, 2024

Thursday, February 1- McLeod and Schneiderat Lawyers presents the 5th annual Snakebite Film Festival. The festival kicks off with a screening of the film "Hairspray" at Landmark Cinemas at 7 p.m. After the screening, there will be a Snakebite Gala at The Black Antler...

You might also like

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act, is shaking up the real estate market.

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act, is shaking up the real estate market.

Are you a property flipper in BC? You might want to pay attention to the new property flipping tax introduced by the government. This tax, officially known as the “residential property (short-term holding) profit tax act,” is shaking up the real estate market.The...

Penticton Vees Dog Race

Penticton Vees Dog Race

The Penticton Vees are hosting their annual Pucks N' Paws night on Saturday, February 17th, and they have something special planned for this year's event. During the first intermission of the game against the West Kelowna Warriors, the Vees will be holding their first...

Powered By

dieno digital